Why the senators race matters in reporting the Alabama abortion ban | Paul Chadwick

Readers argued it was wrong to highlight that the men who voted in the measure were white. But it was central to the story, says the readers editor Paul Chadwick

Why, demanded several readers, does this headline refer to race: These 25 Republicans all white men just voted to ban abortion in Alabama. It was part of the Guardians coverage of the southern US states new measure. The sole exception to the ban is serious risk to the health of the woman; pregnancies resulting from incest or rape are not excepted. Of the 27 Republican men in Alabamas 35-seat senate, 25 voted for the law.


Recommended PRODUCTS
  • Packed full of the info you need for profitable horse racing
  • A Software That Intelligently Calculates The Stakes You Need To Bet And Profit From The Bookies.
  • Earn A Hassle Free Betting Income Every Single Day For The Rest Of Your Life.
  • Know the keys to the pigeon racing secrets that you have always been denied.
  • Discover A Smart Trade Technology That Turns All Of Your Losing Trades Into Winning Trades
  • Are you frustrated that your expensive karoke player does not let you play.
  • Discover how to boost your goal achieving skills in 30 days, guaranteed
  • Race Specialist Definitive Horse Racing Method For Low Risk Winning.
  • Discover How To Add 20lbs To Your Bench Press, 15lbs To Deadlift, And 20lbs To Your Squat In 3 Months
  • Change Your Mind, Change Your Life Influence Your Mind and Others.
  • Discover A Habit Busting Program Gives You The Ability You Have Always Wanted.
  • Know how to eliminate bacterial vaginosis forever in 72 hour.
  • Test that girl is a massive compendium and multimedia course to get girls out on a date
  • Clickbank Ads
     

    Distilled, the readers view was that although it was understandable that the headline would emphasise male dominance, it was wrong to highlight race, too. Wrote one: It detracts and distracts from the real outrage, which is that theyre all male, and theyre all Republican, rather than their skin colour. Another reader thought that the reference to race implied that the votes were motivated by racism. Another wanted the emphasis to stay on the personal moral beliefs of the legislators, whichever way they voted.

    Some readers alleged a breach of the anti-discrimination sections of the Guardian editorial standards, which require that journalists refrain from referring to a persons race or ethnic background unless that information is pertinent to the story. The BBC guidelines express a rationale that is widely shared among journalism codes: Content may reflect the prejudice and disadvantage which exist in societies worldwide but we should not perpetuate it. In some instances, references to race may be relevant to portrayal. However, we should avoid careless or offensive stereotypical assumptions and people should only be described in such terms when editorially justified.

    In this Alabama case, I believe race was highly pertinent. An important aspect of this story is representation, or lack of it. The racial prejudice that has disfigured much in US history, particularly in the south, has manifested in electoral systems, and the effects cannot be left out of account. Of the 50 states, 21 have never sent an African American to Congress.

    The Guardian article could perhaps have distinguished and elaborated better the two aspects of inequality, sex and race. The bulk of it was about the imbalance between numbers of men and women legislators. However, space and time always limit journalism, and the story did say: The Alabama law will disproportionately affect black and poor women, because they are more likely to seek abortions, and less likely to have resources to obtain an abortion out-of-state.

    In essence the article was drawing attention to the unrepresentative makeup of a legislature that had almost entirely outlawed a choice that is a womans to make, in a state where the measure would affect some more than others.

    The Alabama population of 4.8 million was 51.6% female at the time of the most recent census, 2010. A population that is 69% White alone and 27% Black or African American alone, to use US census bureau terms, might reasonably expect similar proportions in its state legislature.

    The Guardian article reported that the proportion of women in the bicameral, 140-member Alabama legislature is 15.7%, compared with 28.7% across all state legislatures. In Alabamas senate the proportion of women is 11.4%, with the representation of black women smaller still.

    Paul Chadwick is the Guardians readers editor

    Original Article : HERE ; This post was curated & posted using : RealSpecific

     


    RELATED PRODUCTS
  • Packed full of the info you need for profitable horse racing
  • Earn A Hassle Free Betting Income Every Single Day For The Rest Of Your Life.
  • Know the keys to the pigeon racing secrets that you have always been denied.
  • A Software That Intelligently Calculates The Stakes You Need To Bet And Profit From The Bookies.
  • Are you frustrated that your expensive karoke player does not let you play.
  • Discover A Smart Trade Technology That Turns All Of Your Losing Trades Into Winning Trades
  • Discover How Your Beliefs and Emotions Affect Your Ability To Achieve All Your Goals And Dreams.
  • Know how to eliminate bacterial vaginosis forever in 72 hour.
  • Scans your computer for missing, corrupt, or outdated Windows Drivers.
  • Cycling training plans and books to create your own training program
  • 135 delicious chocolate desserts from the culinary queens of 100 years ago.
  • Protect Your Family with Parental Controls Download Internet Filter Now
  • Discover The Secret Power To Sneak Into A Man's Mind and Make His Heart Race With Crazy Love For You.
  • Change Your Mind, Change Your Life Influence Your Mind and Others.
  • Clickbank Ads
     

    Thank you for taking the time to read our article.

    If you enjoyed our content, we'd really appreciate some "love" with a share or two.

    And ... Don't forget to have fun!

    Recommended

    A N I M A T I O - Agency / Reseller Rights - 100X

    Animatio is a unique visual Impact App which enables users to fix eyeballs to the page instantly…

    Facebook Marketing 2018 Success Kit Upsell 2

    Get this Up-to-date "Facebook Marketing 2018 Success Kit" with PLR Rights and start cashing in huge by selling it as your own.

    Email Marketing 2.0 Success Kit Downsell

    Get Upgraded package and start selling Email Marketing 2.0 HD video training as your own for 3x Profit.

    Leave a Reply